Call for ministers to make sure hunting trophy ban goes ahead (United
Kingdom)
Nick Eardley, BBC
September 21, 2023
See link https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-politics-66883398 for photo.
The government is facing calls to commit to fresh legislation to fulfil a
manifesto commitment to ban the import of hunting trophies into Great
Britain.
An MP's bill to implement the ban looks all but certain to run out of time
before the end of the parliamentary session.
Ministers have said they still support a ban.
But they are now facing calls to promise to use government time to change
the law next year.
Every year, hunters from the UK travel abroad, often to southern Africa,
and pay thousands of pounds to legally shoot animals, such as lions and
elephants.
Under current rules, with the right paperwork, they can then bring
trophies, such as stuffed heads or horns, back to the UK.
Banning imports from trophy hunting of endangered animals was a commitment
in the 2019 Conservative manifesto.
The measures had been expected in government legislation but ministers
instead backed a private members' bill from Conservative MP Henry Smith.
The legislation would stop hunters bringing back body parts of thousands of
species, including lions, rhinos, elephants, and polar bears, which have
been killed abroad.
It passed the Commons comfortably - but it is currently facing opposition
in the Lords which means it is unlikely to pass before the end of the
parliamentary session on 7 November. That will mean the law goes back to
square one.
Some peers have raised concerns about the impact the legislation could have
on tourism to some African countries.
The bill needs to be approved by both the House of Commons and Lords to
become law.
Government insiders have now conceded the bill is likely to run out of time.
But they have not yet committed to resurrecting it in the King's Speech,
which sets out the legislation the government intends to pursue in the next
parliamentary session.
Mr Smith said: "A couple of peers have held it hostage. It's been
effectively vetoed by a small handful of unelected people."
He added: "I will be calling for the government to introduce it in the
King's Speech."
Claire Bass, from animal welfare campaign group Humane Society
International/UK, said: "In sabotaging this bill a tiny minority of Tory
peers have defied the government, their party, the House of Commons, and
public opinion.
"They have used underhand tactics to wreck it, and delivered an
extraordinarily shameless defence of the colonial relic that is trophy
hunting."
She added that it would be "an exceptionally weak government that would
simply accept this betrayal and abandon its manifesto commitment" and
called for the legislation to be brought back as a government bill.
Labour's shadow environmental secretary, Steve Reed, said: "We must stop
the selfish trophy hunters who want to slaughter then display endangered
animals' body parts for their own perverse self-gratification.
"The Conservative government must stop siding with these killers.
"If they refuse to act, they will be complicit in the slaughter as they
break yet another pre-election promise. The next Labour government will do
the right thing and ban the sickening import of these trophies."
South Africa, Namibia, Tanzania and Zambia have all expressed concerns
through their high commissioners, arguing the proposed law "will undermine
revenue models which provide incentives to local communities in our
countries to maintain wildlife habitats and protect animals from poaching".
Other critics of the proposed ban have argued that profits from hunting are
used to pay for conservation projects in African countries and can
ultimately help to protect endangered species.
However, animal welfare charities have rejected this, claiming that hardly
any of the revenues from trophy hunting ever reach local communities.
Biodiversity Minister Trudy Harrison said: "I am disappointed that despite
the overwhelming support from MPs and the public, the Hunting Trophies Bill
failed to progress in the House of Lords.
"We will continue working to deliver this important manifesto commitment."
https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-politics-66883398
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-12546881/African-leaders-hail-end-controversial-Trophy-Hunting-Bill.html
https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2023/sep/21/resurrect-bill-to-ban-selfish-imports-of-hunting-trophies-to-uk-labour-urges
https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/labour-bill-mps-government-conservative-b2415950.html
Call for ministers to make sure hunting trophy ban goes ahead (United
Kingdom)
Nick Eardley, BBC
September 21, 2023
See link <https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-politics-66883398> for photo.
The government is facing calls to commit to fresh legislation to fulfil a
manifesto commitment to ban the import of hunting trophies into Great
Britain.
An MP's bill to implement the ban looks all but certain to run out of time
before the end of the parliamentary session.
Ministers have said they still support a ban.
But they are now facing calls to promise to use government time to change
the law next year.
Every year, hunters from the UK travel abroad, often to southern Africa,
and pay thousands of pounds to legally shoot animals, such as lions and
elephants.
Under current rules, with the right paperwork, they can then bring
trophies, such as stuffed heads or horns, back to the UK.
Banning imports from trophy hunting of endangered animals was a commitment
in the 2019 Conservative manifesto.
The measures had been expected in government legislation but ministers
instead backed a private members' bill from Conservative MP Henry Smith.
The legislation would stop hunters bringing back body parts of thousands of
species, including lions, rhinos, elephants, and polar bears, which have
been killed abroad.
It passed the Commons comfortably - but it is currently facing opposition
in the Lords which means it is unlikely to pass before the end of the
parliamentary session on 7 November. That will mean the law goes back to
square one.
Some peers have raised concerns about the impact the legislation could have
on tourism to some African countries.
The bill needs to be approved by both the House of Commons and Lords to
become law.
Government insiders have now conceded the bill is likely to run out of time.
But they have not yet committed to resurrecting it in the King's Speech,
which sets out the legislation the government intends to pursue in the next
parliamentary session.
Mr Smith said: "A couple of peers have held it hostage. It's been
effectively vetoed by a small handful of unelected people."
He added: "I will be calling for the government to introduce it in the
King's Speech."
Claire Bass, from animal welfare campaign group Humane Society
International/UK, said: "In sabotaging this bill a tiny minority of Tory
peers have defied the government, their party, the House of Commons, and
public opinion.
"They have used underhand tactics to wreck it, and delivered an
extraordinarily shameless defence of the colonial relic that is trophy
hunting."
She added that it would be "an exceptionally weak government that would
simply accept this betrayal and abandon its manifesto commitment" and
called for the legislation to be brought back as a government bill.
Labour's shadow environmental secretary, Steve Reed, said: "We must stop
the selfish trophy hunters who want to slaughter then display endangered
animals' body parts for their own perverse self-gratification.
"The Conservative government must stop siding with these killers.
"If they refuse to act, they will be complicit in the slaughter as they
break yet another pre-election promise. The next Labour government will do
the right thing and ban the sickening import of these trophies."
South Africa, Namibia, Tanzania and Zambia have all expressed concerns
through their high commissioners, arguing the proposed law "will undermine
revenue models which provide incentives to local communities in our
countries to maintain wildlife habitats and protect animals from poaching".
Other critics of the proposed ban have argued that profits from hunting are
used to pay for conservation projects in African countries and can
ultimately help to protect endangered species.
However, animal welfare charities have rejected this, claiming that hardly
any of the revenues from trophy hunting ever reach local communities.
Biodiversity Minister Trudy Harrison said: "I am disappointed that despite
the overwhelming support from MPs and the public, the Hunting Trophies Bill
failed to progress in the House of Lords.
"We will continue working to deliver this important manifesto commitment."
https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-politics-66883398
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-12546881/African-leaders-hail-end-controversial-Trophy-Hunting-Bill.html
https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2023/sep/21/resurrect-bill-to-ban-selfish-imports-of-hunting-trophies-to-uk-labour-urges
https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/labour-bill-mps-government-conservative-b2415950.html