Namibia, Facing Drought, Plans to Kill Elephants for Meat
Amelia Nierenberg,The New York Times
August 29, 2024
The Southern African nation of Namibia is planning to butcher hundreds of
its most majestic animals to feed some of the 1.4 million people — nearly
half the country — who are in a hunger crisis amid the worst drought in a
century.
The plan, under which the country will kill 723 wild animals, including 83
elephants, to feed people, is “necessary” and “in line with our
constitutional mandate where our natural resources are used for the benefit
of Namibian citizens,” the country’s ministry of environment, forestry and
tourism said in a news release.
This strategy is not unheard-of. “Well-managed, sustainable harvesting of
healthy wild animal populations can be a precious source of food for
communities,” Rose Mwebaza, the director of the United Nations Environment
Programme’s Africa Office, wrote in an email.
Much of Southern Africa is being affected by drought. More than 30 million
people across the region are affected, the U.N. World Food Program said in
June.
Droughts are common in Southern Africa, and the region has experienced
several in the past decade, including from 2018 to 2021, Benjamin Suarato,
a spokesman for the U.S. Agency for International Development, said in an
email. But this one has been especially devastating and widespread across
the region, said Juliane Zeidler, the country director of the World
Wildlife Fund in Namibia.
“There is no food,” Dr. Zeidler said on Thursday. “There is no food for
people and there is no food for animals.”
That’s in large part because of El Niño, a naturally occurring climate
pattern that is often associated with warmer, dryer weather in parts of the
world. It returned last year and “has led to a record-breaking drought with
some parts of the region receiving less than half the annual rainfall,” Mr.
Suarato said.
As the drought dries out staple crops and kills livestock in the region,
Namibia is looking past agriculture to its wild animals for food.
In addition to elephants, the country also plans to butcher 300 zebras, 30
hippos, 50 impalas, 60 buffaloes, 100 blue wildebeest and 100 elands (a
type of antelope).
The animals are not just being killed for meat. Namibia is also trying to
minimize dangerous encounters with humans which, it said, would be expected
to increase during the drought as animals and humans sought out water and
vegetation. (Though elephants are herbivores, they can be deadly. They
killed at least 50 people in Zimbabwe last year, Reuters reported.)
Usually, animals would migrate in cases of severe drought, Dr. Zeidler said.
“But as the drought becomes nationwide,” she said, “there is limited space
to migrate to.”
The situation is dire. Last week, a United Nations spokesman said that 84
percent of Namibia’s food resources were “already exhausted.”
And this is also a particularly tough time of year.
The U.S. aid agency, which announced an additional $4.9 million in
humanitarian assistance last month, said that July through September is the
“peak of the lean season, when food is scarcest.”
Namibia’s turn to wild game is nothing new. People in the region eat at
least some of the animals listed in the environmental ministry’s cull list,
like zebra, blue wildebeest and impala, according to a recent Namibian
government report on the country’s game meat industry.
Eating wild game is common across the world, Dr. Mwebaza said, adding that
the sustainable consumption of bush meat is allowed under the Convention on
Biological Diversity.
“Provided the harvesting of these animals is done using scientifically
proven, sustainable methods that consider animal welfare and are in line
with both domestic and international commitments and legislation, there
should be no cause for concern,” Dr. Mwebaza wrote.
Already, at least 157 animals have been killed, and the ministry said that
their carcasses have yielded about 63 tons of meat.
Namibian officials say that they also hope to mitigate the effect of the
drought on wildlife, saying that the hunt would focus on places where
animals are taxing the water and grazing resources.
Elephants, which can stand over 13 feet tall and weigh over 13,000 pounds,
consume an especially large amount of those resources. They can eat, on
average, about 300 pounds of vegetation a day, Dr. Zeidler said.
Extreme drought killed at least 160 elephants in Zimbabwe’s largest
national park by January and 300 elephants in Botswana last year, according
to Reuters. W.W.F. Namibia is working to raise funds to get water to
elephants and other species in several national parks.
A large conservation reserve across Namibia and four other Southern African
countries includes the world’s largest population of African savanna
elephants, which are endangered and whose population has more than halved
over the last three generations. But in this reserve in recent years, the
elephant population was broadly stable, at more than 227,000 elephants,
according to a 2022 survey.
But now, with the severe drought, those populations are under threat, and
sometimes moving closer to human civilizations.
“Sometimes, you become victim to your own success,” Dr. Zeidler said. “In
years and situations of harshness, it’s a bit more difficult to deal, then,
with these human-wildlife conflicts.”
https://www.nytimes.com/2024/08/29/world/africa/namibia-drought-elephants-meat.html