On Nigeria-Cameroon border, joint patrols throw a lifeline to threatened apes
On Nigeria-Cameroon border, joint patrols throw a lifeline to threatened
apes
Orji Sunday, Mongabay
October 25, 2021
See link
https://news.mongabay.com/2021/10/on-nigeria-cameroon-border-joint-patrols-throw-a-lifeline-to-threatened-apes/
for photos.
Sampson Akoba’s long career as a ranger has left him with a wealth of
assorted memories: hunters’ revolts, the death of his nephew in a violent
encounter with a Nigeria-Cameroon chimpanzee (Pan troglodytes ellioti), and
the smoldering coals of campfires in the cold depths of Nigeria’s
rainforest. Yet, he speaks of his participation in a joint Nigeria-Cameroon
patrol as a defining moment.
This morning, Akoba sits on a plastic armchair, in a narrow corridor
leading to a backyard and a wooden outdoor kitchen. “It was a lovely
experience … a special patrol,” Akoba tells Mongabay as he stares at the
curtain of fog and raindrops beyond his veranda in Butatong, a small
farming community in Nigeria’s Cross River state.
The rugged, forested border between Nigeria and Cameroon was long neglected
by officials, creating an opening exploited by elephant poachers, ape body
part hunters, loggers and fishers. In the 1990s, however, conservationists
and wildlife researchers began to focus more attention on the corridor,
inspired by its biodiversity and its long-term value for conservation in
the region. The research efforts, over time, matured into diverse forms of
collaborations, including an occasional transboundary patrol.
In 2006, at the outset of the patrol program, Akoba joined a team of
rangers from Nigeria’s National Park Service and a group of eco-guards from
the contiguous Takamanda National Park (then a reserve) in Cameroon for a
joint training led by the Wildlife Conservation Society (WCS). The
training, he says, aimed to improve the physical condition of the rangers,
their knowledge of emergency first aid, swimming skills, use of firearms,
as well as combat skills for dealing with aggressive poachers and, later,
the use of firearms.
Weeks later, the freshly trained joint patrol team destroyed dozens of
hunting camps, recovered hunting rifles, arrested poachers, and intercepted
fishers who had poisoned the rivers in the border territory. Old border
markers, faded by years of disuse, and beacons buried in the forest bed,
were retraced. Rangers recorded traces of forest elephants (Loxodonta
cyclotis) moving and feeding, and signs of apes, especially the Cross River
gorilla (Gorilla gorilla diehli).
Africa’s most endangered ape, with an estimated population of just 300
individuals, this gorilla subspecies is found in Afi Mountain Wildlife
Sanctuary, Mbe Mountains Community Sanctuary, and the Okwangwo division of
Cross River National Park and protected sites in neighboring Cameroon. On
both sides of the border, the gorillas face pressure from hunting, logging
and the bushmeat trade.
In addition to gorillas and elephants, this transboundary ecosystem is also
home to endangered Nigeria-Cameroon chimpanzee, drills (Mandrillus
leucophaeus), and other primates, forest buffalos, duikers and diverse
trees and birds.
“For the first time, poachers realized that there is now law enforcement
presence in the area,” Akoba says, reflecting on the impacts of the
patrols. “And it made many of them limit their hunting activities. They
knew it was now more risky to hunt animals around the border. We knew a lot
of apes and elephants use that terrain.”
The rugged, forested border between Nigeria and Cameroon was long neglected
by officials, creating an opening exploited by elephant poachers, ape body
part hunters, loggers and fishers.
Ongoing Efforts
Conservationists continue to explore means to reduce and counter threats to
animals in the region, including workshops and surveys facilitated by NGOs
and wildlife researchers, and sometimes involving both governments and
their national parks agencies.
The efforts have improved intelligence sharing and transnational law
enforcement between wildlife authorities in Nigeria and Cameroon. Exchange
visits, complete with research, have been growing, as well as awareness and
educational campaigns targeted at enclave communities on both sides of the
border. Following a 2006 workshop, officials, researchers and NGOs settled
on a priority action plan to improve national and cross border protection
of apes in the region. This action plan has continuously been reviewed,
taking fresh threats into account as well as shared interest and progress
of the previous years.
“In the past, poachers kill animals in Cameroon and run to Nigeria to hide.
Also, hunters who poach in Nigeria flee to Cameroon to hide,” says Akom
Albert, a ranger with Nigeria’s National Park Service. For example, more
than 20 illegal loggers recently arrested in Cameroon claimed to be
Nigerians. The new system allows for the loggers to be prosecuted in
Cameroon, the country where their alleged crimes were committed. The
elevation of Takamanda Forest Reserve to a National Park in 2008 marked
another milestone.
As is common with such cross-border collaborations, there have been rough
patches, says Emmanual Bassey, WCS project coordinator in the Cross River
landscape. Changes of government, along with broader political instability,
have derailed some goals and projects. Parties, sometimes more keen on
projecting national agendas, can sometimes approach negotiations and
collective conservation actions with less vigor.
The biggest issue, sources say, is sorting out and signing paperwork, a
process that can prove slow and complicated. Oluwole Ojewale of South
Africa-based think tank the Institute for Security Studies attributes the
paperwork drudgery partly to “lack of political will” and a mindset that
looks upon the forest as a potential source of immediate profit.
Numerous local and international laws aimed at the protection of apes and
related species are poorly enforced, he says. These flaws, along with
corruption within law enforcement agencies, poor funding, and the
proliferation of firearms, mean that threats to wildlife and timber in the
border terrain remain high.
While administrative and political issues can stymie progress at the top,
on-the-ground law enforcement faces its own set of obstacles. Rangers place
their lives at risk trekking through tangled forests in the thick darkness
and wading through swollen rivers. The border territories are a labyrinth
of rivers and tributaries that often overflow during heavy rains. Bassey
reports close brushes with death resulting from attempting to cross rivers
while exhausted by long treks and heavy gear. Snakebites are equally a
common threat, in forests that are home to cobras, mambas and vipers; some
bites can be too much for regular antivenom to counteract. Exposure to rain
and extreme cold can also contribute to rangers falling too sick to see out
a patrol.
Handling these emergencies can be tricky. Nearby communities are often
hours, if not days, away. Deciding to take a sick ranger or eco-guard to
the nearest community invariably brings the patrol to a halt. In 2017,
Bassey recalls, one of the rangers fell ill in the heart of the forest,
only a few days into a patrol. He was vomiting became too week to walk. The
patrol had to be called off and it took three days to get him to the
nearest community, where he received preliminary medical care. “There are
many such near-death experiences,” Bassey tells Mongabay.
Other times, the threats come from poachers, who either form alliances to
resist arrest or collude with local communities to ambush patrol teams.
Rangers can face pressure to surrender arrested poachers, a tactic that
sometimes succeeds because the isolated nature of these locations makes
calling in reinforcements nearly impossible. After a few such encounters
with armed poachers and communities, both countries agreed to equip
transboundary rangers with firearms to increase their chances of arresting
aggressive poachers or at least escaping unhurt.
The Cameroonian Crisis
It’s been more than three years since the last cross-border patrol was
conducted, due to the ongoing political crisis in Cameroon. What started in
2018 as a low-key protest by teachers and lawyers from Cameroon’s
English-speaking region, who complained of domination by their
French-speaking compatriots, matured into a full-blown crisis in which more
than 4,000 people have been killed and 760,000 displaced. Of the latter,
around 60,000 fled to Nigeria through forest tracks, mountains and rivers.
Wildlife officials at several of Cameroon’s national parks fled at the
outset of the crisis because separatists were known to target government
institutions and their employees, says Eric Tah, deputy director of The
Last Great Apes Organization (LAGA), an international NGO that supports the
enforcement of wildlife laws in Cameroon. “None of the parks in the crisis
area enjoys any sort of protection,” Tah says. Numerous foreign-funded
conservation projects, at various degrees of execution, have been abandoned
or temporarily suspended.
Tah says that with the vast numbers crossing through the forest to Nigeria,
“wildlife must suffer.” Mongabay found that some of the refugees crossing
over from Cameroon had settled in forest communities in Cross River,
serving as cheap labor for loggers. Their survival is intricately linked to
the forest as government support has been limited. There are also rumors
that separatist fighters are using the forest, particularly parts that
overlap with the gorilla range, as a haven.
While this news is troubling for conservationists, Tah says the biggest
fear comes from the unknown: There is total information blackout from
crucial conservation hotspots around Cameroon, especially in regions
affected by the lingering crisis. “Nobody can say for sure whether
separatist fighters are using the wildlife in those parks. It is impossible
to return to work in those areas. Takamanda National Park, where we have
the Cross River gorilla, is at the center of the crisis,” Tah says.
“If there is one species that might likely suffer the most because of the
crisis, it has to be the Cross River gorilla,” he adds. “At the end of this
crisis, we might not have any more Cross River gorillas in this country. We
are very, very worried”
In 2020, Bassey of WCS and his team began mounting camera traps around the
border region to get a sense of the activities of animals and poachers
alike. “The camera traps caught three elephant poachers,” he says. After a
follow-up investigation, WCS found that two of the three poachers, who had
rifles, were Nigerians. The third person was probably a Cameroonian guide.
The poachers probably attacked three elephants, of which two escaped with
bullet wounds while one died. Bassey shows Mongabay the butchered skull of
a baby elephant recovered during the investigation, saying that at least 10
elephants might have been killed in that area in the past year.
As the crisis festers, Tah says, gorillas on both sides of the border face
increased risk of genetic isolation and inbreeding due to limited
interactions between the subpopulations in Nigeria and Cameroon — a major
fear for conservationists. As early as 2008, a study of genetic diversity
among various types of gorillas found that Cross River gorillas had “lower
levels of diversity” than the more numerous western lowland gorillas
(Gorilla gorilla gorilla), and that genetic evidence suggested Cross River
gorillas had recently gone through a genetic bottleneck, or rapid reduction
in population size, that affected the species’ fitness.
World Heritage Aspirations
Amid the chaos in Cameroon, both governments have continued to explore
alternatives to keep some projects going through virtual interactions. More
camera traps will now be deployed along the margins of Cross River National
Park, toward the border areas, Bassey says.
WCS sources say talks are now underway to harmonize wildlife legislation
and policies, and possibly form a unified central law enforcement unit with
regional commands. There are also plans to expand livelihood support for
communities living within the park’s boundaries, whose dependence on forest
resources continues to deepen due to lack of jobs, poverty, and population
growth.
However, the biggest aspiration for the future is to merge the major
national parks where gorillas and chimpanzees occur into a single
territory, elevated to a UNESCO World Heritage Site. A working group to
facilitate the process, consisting of representatives from NGOs and both
governments, has been meeting since 2016.
“The future looks good for our transboundary efforts. The level of
commitment from both governments has been good,” says Inaoyom Imong,
director of the Cross River landscape at WCS. When this is done, he adds,
it will likely trigger more funding and support and urgency for
conservation efforts in this region.